:: Encore Theatre Magazine ::
:: British Theatre: Polemics & Positions ::| [::..navigation..::] |
|---|
| :: Encore Revivals |
| :: Encore Heroes |
| :: Encore Futures |
| :: Encore Snapshots |
| :: Encore Polemics |
| :: Encore Resources |
| :: Encore Criticwatch |
| :: Encore Commentary |
| :: Encore on Encore |
| :: Encore Awards 2003 |
| [::..site feeds..::] |
| :: Atom |
| :: RSS |
Encore Theatre Magazine
::Front Page::
:: Wednesday, January 10, 2007 ::
Billington's BlairMichael Billington's put up a more than usually will-this-do?-ish piece on the Guardian's theatre blog.Titled, for no very good reason, 'How do you solve a problem like Blair?' he uses the announcements of two 'Tony Blair on Trial' plays, one on C4 and one at the Tricycle, to observe that Blair so far 'has been seen on stage largely as a buffoon'. Instead, Michael longs for a play that 'takes Blair seriously'.
Well, there is something to be said for this point. The kind of lampooning you get in The Madness of George Dubya or Follow My Leader makes those of us who opposed the Iraq occupation feel good but it doesn't add to our understanding. Nor, one might add, were they really meant to.
But what does Billington mean by taking Blair seriously? He offers two definitions: one 'that examines Blair in all his psychological complexity' or 'one that even portrays him as a tragic figure'. What does this mean? Here Billington pads the article out with some very meandering thoughts but he seems to believe that Blair's tragedy is that he did the wrong thing for the right reasons, at least in his own eyes. By 'the wrong thing' he means enter into this murderous war (is that what he means by the reference to 'the accumulating corpses'? It was a war, Michael...). But it's utterly mysterious what he could mean by 'the right reasons'.
Why did we go to war? Blair is fond now of claiming that he did so in order to depose the tyrant, Saddam Hussein. But this is a rereading of history. Blair took us into war on the basis of the WMD Saddam Hussein supposedly possessed and was seeking to develop. There is much l;ess talk about his oppression of his own people. If you look at the two main dossiers of information released to the press and public, the February ('dodgy') dossier and the September dossier, the great preponderance and primary focus of both is on the WMD intelligence. In the February dossier, only three pages directly refer to the oppression of the Iraqi people; the long second section outlining the structure of the internal security apparatus seems largely informative and as much talking about, say, the role of the Republican Guard in defeating the weapons inspectors as in discussing the security's role in repressing dissidence. In the September dossier, the one directly made available to the public, Blair's introduction comprises 29 sentences, 15 of which relate directly to the threat posed by the WMD. In contrast, there is one reference to Saddam Hussein's 'dictatorial' behaviour. It is clear that it was the imminent threat to Britain posed by Saddam Hussein, not that of his own people, that was Blair's central argument in support of military action.This makes a difference because the kinds of questions you ask someone claiming self-defence (even anticipatory self-defence) are quite different from those claiming humanitarian intervention. If Iraq had posed a direct threat to the West, we would have been quite right to intervene militarily - once diplomatic routes had broken down. Few other questions would have been asked. If we had claimed it was a humanitarian intervention, other questions come into the picture: why now? (the September dossier lists human rights abuses going back twenty years) and why Iraq? (rather than, say, Zimbabwe, or North Korea, or any one of several oppressive regimes). By claiming the first ground, he avoids the second set of questions, and so he cannot change position now. It is a central plank of any 'just war' that you declare, beforehand, why you are embarking upon it. This Blair did not do.So if Billington means that for the right reasons (deposing Saddam Hussein) Blair did the wrong thing (went to war), he's seriously misled. And in any case, why would this be illuminated by presenting a rounded pictrure of Blair in all his psychological complexity? Answer: it wouldn't. It would be a distraction from the real forces that are at work here, and these are not psychological. They are an embedded Foreign Office doctrine that will not let us break with America, in a mistaken belief that we hold a balance of forces between the US, Europe and the Commonwealth. They are an ideological programme called Project for the New American Century. It's our addiction to air travel, America's addiction to fuck-off cars, the emerging economies of China and India, and the need to stabilise the diminishing oil supply because the US presidency is bought by the oil companies.
Yes, I think there is some kind of tragic story here. Blair over-reached himself in believing that he could persuade the UN to get behind military action in Iraq. But he couldn't, because they didn't believe he had them, didn't really think he was obstructing the weapons inspectors, and saw the American aggression for what it was. Naked self-interest, a neo-neo strategy, the revival of Kissingerism, and that was never going to be good for the world. But to claim that his story is the one we need to see is to buy into Blair's own self-importance and a UK foreign office view of the world.To understand what has happened in Iraq, we must resist Blair: The Tragedy.Labels: Billington Blair Politics Iraq
:: posted by Theatre Worker at Wednesday, January 10, 2007
...
.jpg)
Comments:
By the sound of it, from Front Row at least, the C4 play is along the lines of the tragic approach to Blair that you urge us to ‘resist’.
I for one am glad. It’s a great narrative, one I don’t feel necessitates me buying into ‘a UK foreign office view of the world’ to appreciate. Here is a fantastically able politician and a devout, decent man who has made a massive mistake. The really important thing is that the ramifications of that mistake, the thousands of deaths and the millions of people who think less of this country internationally, cannot be skirted over. They must take centre-stage.
I can’t speak for Billington, (you do spend a lot of time on his back, has he slagged you off in the past?) but could the ‘wrong deed’ be taking us into a war on the basis of false information, for the ‘in his eyes, right reason’ of humanitarian intervention? This is the case as made by the ‘Liberal Neo-con’ journalists who are thought to share Blair’s thinking on this – guys like Hitchens, Aaronovitch and Hari, a representative of whom found their way into ‘Stuff Happens’.
As TB’s tenure has come to an end there’s inevitably a lot of talk about his legacy and his achievements. What stands out is how, were it not for this war, he might’ve been thought of as one of the two or three great post war Prime Ministers.
I can’t help thinking how ripe that is for the tragedy treatment.
I for one am glad. It’s a great narrative, one I don’t feel necessitates me buying into ‘a UK foreign office view of the world’ to appreciate. Here is a fantastically able politician and a devout, decent man who has made a massive mistake. The really important thing is that the ramifications of that mistake, the thousands of deaths and the millions of people who think less of this country internationally, cannot be skirted over. They must take centre-stage.
I can’t speak for Billington, (you do spend a lot of time on his back, has he slagged you off in the past?) but could the ‘wrong deed’ be taking us into a war on the basis of false information, for the ‘in his eyes, right reason’ of humanitarian intervention? This is the case as made by the ‘Liberal Neo-con’ journalists who are thought to share Blair’s thinking on this – guys like Hitchens, Aaronovitch and Hari, a representative of whom found their way into ‘Stuff Happens’.
As TB’s tenure has come to an end there’s inevitably a lot of talk about his legacy and his achievements. What stands out is how, were it not for this war, he might’ve been thought of as one of the two or three great post war Prime Ministers.
I can’t help thinking how ripe that is for the tragedy treatment.
# posted by 
: 10/1/07 8:32 AM
: 10/1/07 8:32 AM
And if you have read all the Iraq books that it sounds like you have, then you’ll know the governments and major industries of both Russia and France had millions of dollars invested in Iraq and thus their own good reasons not to invade. Ascribing perspicacity and noble motives to all the UN in this matter is silly. Sillier than Billington is in his piece.
# posted by : 10/1/07 8:41 AM
: 10/1/07 8:41 AM
Here's a question: Has there ever been a dramatically rounded and convincing portrayal of a prime minister in a play? I can think of plenty of tremendously engaging and moving kings, but that's not the same thing! Churchill in Hochhuth's 'Soldiers' is the most convincing as a man and as a bearer of enormous power that I can think of - off the top of my head - with the Prime Minister in Granville Barker's 'Waste' being the most interesting ficticious one.
# posted by : 10/1/07 10:34 AM
: 10/1/07 10:34 AM
Interesting point, Brace, but why does what you say amount to saying that Blair's story has the form of a 'tragedy'. Yeah maybe in the loose everyday use of the term (where every child's death is a tragedy) but that's not what Billington meant is it?
# posted by : 10/1/07 2:18 PM
: 10/1/07 2:18 PM
I expect he meant it in the ancient Greek sense: a great man who is the progenitor of his own downfall, which is how I meant it too.
# posted by : 10/1/07 4:57 PM
: 10/1/07 4:57 PM
Representing what happened as a tragedy individualises the issue as if it's all about his mental fight and his loss of reputation, which frankly doesn't seem all that significant compared to the Iraqi civilian death toll so far.
Isn't Encore's point that you get a better understanding of what's happened by not making Blair at the centre of it. Which is quite literalist of them of course, and did you guys like Stuff Happens? That certainly put Tony Blair way off-centre.
Isn't Encore's point that you get a better understanding of what's happened by not making Blair at the centre of it. Which is quite literalist of them of course, and did you guys like Stuff Happens? That certainly put Tony Blair way off-centre.
# posted by : 10/1/07 5:38 PM
: 10/1/07 5:38 PM
Interestingly (and this relates to a point Paul Miller has made on his blog) Encore were rather positive about Stuff Happens when it first came out but were scathing about it in the recent piece on Amy's View.
# posted by : 11/1/07 11:20 AM
: 11/1/07 11:20 AM
That may be because we don't always agree between ourselves, which is relatively healthy. Some of us thought Stuff Happens was a very dull way of talking about politics (40 blokes in identical grey suits). Some thought it was a very exciting event and - let's face it - those audience were among the largest gatherings of those (largely) opposed to the invasion of Iraq since the march of 15 February 2003.
I agree with Steve's point above. Why individualise this story so much? How genuinely illuminating is it to treat Blair's escapade as the downfall of a great man, or his undoing by some tragic flaw. Do we need catharsis in this situation? The tragedy is not in Blair's likely drubbing at the hands of history, it is ongoing right across the Middle East.
It's interesting to reflect on Simon's question about representations of Prime Ministers. Hollywood produced the movie Air Force One in which terrorists hijack the President's plane and, through a mixture of skill, cunning, and a physical prowess he defeats them. It's pretty well impossible to imagine pitching the same film about a British prime minister. Is this because they're comfortable about heroism in a way that we're not? They have The West Wing which is broadly heroic and we have The Thick of It. They have The American President, we have Love, Actually. This may underlie Billington's question about the buffoonery that characterises all representations of Blair. What very positive representations of Prime Ministers have there been since the war? Ian Curteis's The Falklands Play was risible wasn't it? ('Those poor sailors...')
I agree with Steve's point above. Why individualise this story so much? How genuinely illuminating is it to treat Blair's escapade as the downfall of a great man, or his undoing by some tragic flaw. Do we need catharsis in this situation? The tragedy is not in Blair's likely drubbing at the hands of history, it is ongoing right across the Middle East.
It's interesting to reflect on Simon's question about representations of Prime Ministers. Hollywood produced the movie Air Force One in which terrorists hijack the President's plane and, through a mixture of skill, cunning, and a physical prowess he defeats them. It's pretty well impossible to imagine pitching the same film about a British prime minister. Is this because they're comfortable about heroism in a way that we're not? They have The West Wing which is broadly heroic and we have The Thick of It. They have The American President, we have Love, Actually. This may underlie Billington's question about the buffoonery that characterises all representations of Blair. What very positive representations of Prime Ministers have there been since the war? Ian Curteis's The Falklands Play was risible wasn't it? ('Those poor sailors...')
But are there positive, heroic representations of US presidents in American theatre (as opposed to film and TV)?
And going back to the point about British representations of monarchs compared to prime ministers, does royalty still capture the British imagination more than party politics? Though, having said that, Peter Morgan's done a rather fine job at representating both Tony and Liz.
And going back to the point about British representations of monarchs compared to prime ministers, does royalty still capture the British imagination more than party politics? Though, having said that, Peter Morgan's done a rather fine job at representating both Tony and Liz.
achat antivirus anti spyware gratuit anti spyware anti virus software antivirus gratuit avast antivirus gratuit avast antivirus avg antivirus antivirus com comparatif antivirus antivirus download antivirus en ligne gratuit antivirus firewall antivirus gratuit francais antivirus free antivirus gratis antivirus gratui antivirus gratuis avast antivirus gratuit antivirus ligne gratuit antivirus gratuit francais antivirus kaspersky antivirus mac antivirus mcafee antivirus online panda antivirus antivirus personal edition antivirus pour scanner antivirus protection antivirus review antivirus wanadoo antivirus a telecharger antivirus en ligne antivirus gratuit a telecharger antivirus gratuit antivirus gratuitement antivirus norton antivirus software antivirus avast antivirus gratuit avast antivirus avast avg antivirus avg bitdefender comparatif antivirus firewall antivirus free antivirus kaspersky logiciel antivirus gratuit logiciel antivirus logiciels antivirus gratuit logiciels antivirus mc afee meilleur antivirus norton 2005 norton 2006 norton antivirus 2005 norton antivirus 2006 norton antivirus norton ghost norton internet security norton panda antivirus panda software personal firewall antivirus protection remove spyware security software spybot search and destroy spyware removal spyware remover spyware symantec antivirus telechargement anti virus gratuit telechargement anti virus telechargement antivirus gratuit telechargement antivirus telechargement antivirus gratuit telechargement antivirus telechargements anti virus gratuit telechargements anti virus telechargements antivirus gratuit telecharger antivirus gratuit telecharger antivirus telecharger avast telecharger norton antivirus telecharger anti virus gratuit telecharger antivirus gratuit telecharger antivirus gratuitement telecharger antivirus telecharger avast telecharger gratuitement anti virus test antivirus ecran de veille a telecharger gratuitement fond and ecran fond d ecran 3d fond d ecran a telecharger fond d ecran amour fond ecran animé fond d ecran anne geddes fond d ecran chat fond d ecran cheval fond ecran cinema fond d ecran dauphin fond d ecran diddl fond d ecran disney fond d ecran f1 fond d ecran fleurs fond d ecran gratuit fond d ecran humour fond d ecran mangas fond d ecran montagne fond d ecran moto fond d ecran nature fond d ecran ordinateur fond d ecran paysage fond d ecran pc gratuit fond d ecran pc fond ecran psp fond d ecran sexy fond d ecran tuning fond d ecran fond ecran 3d fond d ecran animal fond d ecran anne geddes fond d ecran aquarium fond ecran bebe fond d ecran chat fond d ecran cheval fond ecran chien fond d ecran dauphin fond d ecran diddl fond d ecran disney fond d ecran fleurs fond d ecran gratuit fond d ecran humour fond d ecran mangas fond ecran mobile fond ecran montagne fond d ecran moto fond d ecran nature fond ecran om fond d ecran ordinateur fond d ecran paysage fond d ecran pc gratuit fond d ecran pc fond ecran portable fond ecran printemps fond d ecran psp fond ecran saint valentin fond d ecran sexy fond d ecran star wars fond d ecran tuning fond ecran voiture fonds and d ecran fonds and ecran fonds d ecran 3d fonds d ecran amour fonds d ecran anne geddes fonds d ecran chat fonds d ecran cheval fonds ecran cinema fonds d ecran dauphin fonds d ecran diddl fonds d ecran disney fonds d ecran f1 fonds d ecran fleurs fonds d ecran gratuit fonds d ecran humour fonds d ecran mangas fonds d ecran montagne fonds d ecran moto fonds d ecran nature fonds d ecran ordinateur fonds d ecran paysage fonds d ecran pc gratuit fonds d ecran pc fonds ecran psp fonds d ecran sexy fonds d ecran tuning fonds d ecran fonds ecran 3d fonds d ecran animal fonds ecran anime fonds d ecran anne geddes fonds d ecran aquarium fonds ecran bebe fonds d ecran chat fonds d ecran cheval fonds ecran chien fonds d ecran dauphin fonds d ecran diddl fonds d ecran disney fonds d ecran fleurs fonds d ecran humour fonds d ecran mangas fonds ecran mobile fonds ecran montagne fonds d ecran moto fonds d ecran nature fonds ecran om fonds d ecran ordinateur fonds d ecran paysage fonds d ecran pc gratuit fonds d ecran pc fonds ecran portable fonds ecran printemps fonds d ecran psp fonds ecran saint valentin fonds d ecran sexy fonds d ecran star wars fonds d ecran tuning free wallpapers image fond d ecran image fond d ecran mangas wallpaper photo fond ecran sexy wallpaper telecharger fond d ecran gratuit telecharger fond d ecran telecharger fond ecran wallpaper gratuit wallpaper mangas wallpaper photo wallpaper sexy wallpaper wallpapers gratuit wallpapers mangas wallpapers photo wallpapers sexy wallpapers astrologie chinoise astrologie gratuite astrologie horoscope 2006 gratuit horoscope 2006 horoscope balance horoscope belier horoscope cancer horoscope capricorne horoscope chinois horoscope du jour horoscope gemeau horoscope gratuit horoscope lion horoscope mensuel horoscope poisson horoscope sagittaire horoscope scorpion horoscope taureau horoscope verseau horoscope vierge horoscope jeu de tarot jeux de tarot tarot gratuit tarot tirage tarot gratuit tirage tarot video futur zodiaque icon icone gratuit icone icone gratuit icone icons francaise des jeu francaise des jeux jeu action jeu adulte jeu aventure jeu barbie jeu de carte jeu en ligne gratuit jeu en ligne jeu enfant jeu erotique jeu flash jeu fr jeu en ligne gratuit jeu gratuit jeu online jeu pc jeu sexe jeu sexy jeu solitaire jeu video jeu a telecharger gratuit jeu a telecharger gratuitement jeu a telecharger sur pc jeu a telecharger jeu d avion a telecharger jeu d echec a telecharger jeu de billard a telecharger jeu de carte a telecharger jeu de voiture gratuit jeu de voiture jeu flash a telecharger jeu gratiut a telecharger jeu gratuis a telecharger jeu gratuit a telecharger jeu pc a telecharger gratuit jeu pc a telecharger gratuitement jeu pc a telecharger jeu pc gratuit a telecharger jeu pc telecharger gratuitement jeu pokemon a telecharger jeu pour enfant a telecharger jeu a telecharger gratuitement telecharger jeu jeu video a telecharger gratuitement jeu video a telecharger jeu video com jeu video gratuit a telecharger jeu video gratuit jeu video pc jeu video telecharger jeu video .com jeu jeux action jeux adulte jeux aventure jeux barbie jeux de carte jeux en ligne jeux enfant jeux erotique jeux flash jeux fr jeux en ligne gratuit jeux gratuit jeux online jeux pc jeux sexe jeux sexy jeux solitaire jeux video jeux a telecharger gratuit jeux a telecharger gratuitement jeux a telecharger sur pc jeux a telecharger jeux d avion a telecharger jeux d echec a telecharger jeux de billard a telecharger jeux de carte a telecharger jeux de voiture gratuit jeux de voiture jeux flash a telecharger jeux gratiut a telecharger jeux gratuis a telecharger jeux gratuit a telecharger jeux pc a telecharger gratuit jeux pc a telecharger gratuitement jeux pc a telecharger jeux pc gratuit a telecharger jeux pc telecharger gratuitement jeux pokemon a telecharger jeux pour enfant a telecharger telecharger jeux jeux video a telecharger gratuitement jeux video a telecharger jeux video com jeux video gratuit a telecharger jeux video gratuit jeux video pc jeux rom game boy advance rom nintendo 64 rom sims 2 telechargement sims 2 telecharger telecharger les sims 2 telechargement de jeu video telecharger jeu gratuit telechargement jeu telechargement jeux telecharger les sims 2 telecharger jeu complet jeu gratuit a telecharger telecharger jeu pc telecharger jeu video telecharger jeu telecharger jeux pc telecharger jeux telecharger des jeu gratuitement telecharger emulateur telecharger gratuit jeu telecharger jeu complet telecharger jeu flash telecharger jeu gratuit telecharger jeu gratuit telecharger jeu pc gratuit telecharger jeu pc telecharger jeu psp telecharger jeu sims telecharger jeu video telecharger jeu telecharger jeux complet telecharger jeux gratuit telecharger jeux pc telecharger jeux psp telecharger jeux video telecharger jeux telecharger les sims 2 telecharger les sims 2 telecharger les sims gratuit telecharger les sims gratuitement telecharger mario telecharger monopoly telecharger objet sims 2 telecharger objet sims telecharger sims 2 video games achat mp3 album albums baladeur cd mp3 baladeur mp3 fm baladeur mp3 cd musique chanson a telecharger gratuitement chanson a telecharger clip musique clip video convertir mp3 convertisseur mp3 convertisseur wma mp3 divx dvd divx gratuit mp3 download dvd divx dvd film dvd musique dvd pas cher dvd shrink dvd vierge dvd ecouter musique encodeur mp3 telecharger des film gratuitement film a telecharger gratuitement film a telecharger film cinema film divx a telecharger film divx film dvd film gratuit a telecharger film gratuit film pirate telechargement gratuit film telechargement telecharger des film gratuitement film a telecharger film films a telecharger films dvd films gratuit films a telecharger films france musique free mp3 jaquette film jaquette dvd lecteur divx lecteur dvd portable lecteur dvd lecteur mp3 logiciel mp3 logiciel musique logiciels mp3 logiciels musique montage video mp3 arabe baladeur mp3 mp3 creative mp3 download mp3 gratuit musique music mp3 mp3 pas cher player mp3 telecharger mp3 mp3 gratuit telecharger mp3 gratuit mp3 musique mp3 telecharger gratuit mp3 telecharger mp3 music a telecharger music mp3 music video musique telecharger gratuitement musique de pub musique telecharger gratuitement musique telecharge musique a telecharger gratuit musique a telecharger gratuite musique a telecharger gratuitement musique a telecharger musique alsace musique arabe musique classique musique de film musique download musique de film musique francaise musique gratuite a telecharger musique gratuite musique marocaine musique mp3 a telecharger musique mp3 musique musique a telecharge parole et musique partition musique player mp3 sony mp3 telecharge film telechargement cd telechargement chanson telechargement musique gratuitement telechargement divx gratuit telechargement film gratuit telechargement film telechargement films gratuit telechargement films telechargement gratuit chanson telechargement film gratuit telechargement gratuit de music telechargement divx gratuit telechargement gratuit emule telechargement gratuit mp3 telechargement gratuit de musique mp3 telecharger musique gratuite telechargement video gratuit telechargement musique mp3 telechargement gratuit music telechargement music telechargement gratuit musique telecharger musique gratuite telechargement musique mp3 telechargement musique telechargement video gratuit telecharger video telechargement chanson telechargement film cinema telechargement film divx telechargement film gratuit telechargement film telechargement films gratuit telechargement films telechargement gratuit de film telechargement gratuit mp3 telechargement musique gratuit telechargement musique gratuite telechargement musique mp3 telechargement musique telecharger video telechargements antivirus telechargements cd telechargements chanson telechargements de musique gratuitement telechargements divx gratuit telechargements divx telechargements film divx telechargements film gratuit telechargements film porno telechargements film x telechargements film telechargements gratuit de chanson telechargements film gratuit telechargements gratuit de music telechargements divx gratuit telechargements gratuit de musique mp3 telechargements musique gratuite telechargements video gratuit telechargements mp3 telechargements musique gratuite telechargements musique mp3 telechargements video gratuit telechargements video x telechargements video telechargements winzip telechargements gratuit mp3 telecharger album telecharger cd telecharger chanson telecharger des film gratuitement telechargement film gratuit telechargement film telecharger musique gratuite telecharger mp3 gratuit telecharger mp3 telecharger musique gratuite telecharger musique telecharger album musique telecharger album telecharger cd telecharger chanson telecharger chansons telecharger clip video telecharger des chanson gratuitement telecharger des film gratuitement telecharger divx gratuit telecharger divx gratuitement telecharger divx telecharger dvd gratuit telecharger dvd telecharger film divx telecharger film gratuit telecharger film gratuitement telecharger film telecharger films gratuit telecharger films gratuitement telecharger films telecharger gratuit film telecharger gratuitement des chanson telecharger gratuitement musique mp3 telecharger musique gratuite telecharger logiciel mp3 gratuit telecharger logiciel musique telecharger mp3 gratuit telecharger mp3 gratuitement telecharger mp3 telecharger music gratuitement telecharger music mp3 telecharger musique film telecharger musique gratuite telecharger musique gratuitement telecharger musique mp3 gratuit telecharger musique mp3 gratuitement telecharger musique sur mp3 telecharger musique telecharger rap telecharger video telecharger video telecharger video telecharger video video clip video clips video gratuit video gratuite video internet telecharger video video videos gratuit videos gratuites videos adresse msn astuce msn messenger astuce msn avatar msn clean messenger e messenger emoticone msn messenger emoticone a telecharger gratuit emoticone a telecharger emoticone msn hotmail messenger i love messenger installer msn messenger instant messenger windows live messenger logiciel msn logiciels msn logitech quickcam messenger msn messenger 7.0 msn messenger 7 msn messenger 8.0 msn messenger 8 messenger astuce messenger beta messenger fun windows live messenger messenger msn mkt fr yahoo messenger messenger 7.5 messenger 7.5 messenger msn messenger plus messenger mns messenger msm messenger msn messenger 6 msn messenger 7,5 msn messenger 8 msn messenger beta msn messenger gratuit msn messenger mac msn web messenger telecharger msn msn 5 msn 7.0 telecharger msn 7.5 telecharger msn 7.5 msn 7 msn 7.0 msn 7.5 telecharger msn 8.0 msn 8 msn astuce msn fr msn gratuit msn hotmail msn jeu msn messenger 6.2 msn messenger 7.0 msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn messenger 7.5 msn messenger 7 msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn messenger 7.5 msn messenger 8.0 msn messenger plus msn messenger telecharger msn messenger version 7.5 msn messenger version 7.5 msn messenger msn messenger7.5 msn plus telecharger msn plus msn telecharger msn truc astuce msn truc et astuce msn web messenger msn web msn net messenger logitech quickcam messenger skin msn smiley gratuit telecharger smiley msn telechargement gratuit msn telechargement msn 7.5 telechargement msn plus telechargements gratuit msn telechargements msn 7.5 telechargements msn plus telechargements msn 7.5 telecharger msn 7.5 telecharger msn gratuit telecharger msn gratuitement telecharger msn messenger 7.0 telecharger msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn plus telecharger msn telecharger yahoo messenger telecharger emoticone gratuit telecharger emoticone gratuitement telecharger emoticone msn telecharger emoticone telecharger gratuitement des emoticone telecharger gratuitement msn 7.0 telecharger gratuitement msn 7.5 telecharger gratuitement msn messenger 7.0 telecharger gratuitement msn messenger telecharger gratuitement msn plus telecharger gratuitement msn telecharger messenger 7.0 telecharger messenger 7.5 telecharger messenger 7 telecharger messenger 7.5 telecharger messenger plus telecharger messenger telecharger msn 7 gratuitement telecharger msn 7.0 gratuitement telecharger msn 7.0 telecharger msn 7.5 francais telecharger msn 7.5 telecharger msn 7.5 francais telecharger msn 7.5 telecharger msn 8.0 telecharger msn 8.0 telecharger msn beta telecharger msn gratuit telecharger msn gratuitement telecharger msn mesenger telecharger msn messager telecharger msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn messenger 8.0 telecharger msn messenger 8.0 telecharger msn messenger gratuit telecharger msn messenger gratuitement telecharger msn messenger plus telecharger msn messenger7.0 telecharger msn plus gratuitement telecharger msn plus telecharger msn version 7.5 telecharger msn msn web messenger msn web messenger web messenger windows live messenger windows messenger yahoo messenger 6.0 yahoo messenger 6 yahoo messenger chef recette cocktail recette asiatique recette barbecue recette cake recette chinoise recette cocktail recette cookie recette courgette recette crepe recette de confiture recette de cuisine recette de julie recette de salade recette dessert recette facile recette gateau chocolat recette gateau recette gaufre recette italienne recette minceur recette paella recette pain recette pizza recette poisson recette poulet recette punch recette rapide recette sangria recette tarte recette recettes asiatique recettes cake recettes chinoises recettes cookies recettes crepe recettes de cuisine recettes desserts recettes gateau recettes gaufre recettes italienne recettes pizza recettes poisson recettes poulet recettes rapide recettes tarte recettes robe de cocktail amateur couple amateur gay amateur gratuit amateur libertin amateur nu amateur porno amateur sex amateur sexe amateur video amateur webcam amateur x amateur amatrice sexe amerique latine anal destruction anal dildo anal fist anal fisting anal gratuit anal sex anal anime asiatique nu asiatique baise black bear gay beau sein beaute femme belle bite belle black belle chatte belle femme nu belle femme belle fille belle poitrine belle salope beur gay beurette salope bite au cul bite black bite cheval bite gay black anal black and white black cock black decker black dick black gay black girl black girls black nu black porn black porno black pussy black sex black sexe black sexy black teen black teens black tits black women blacks on blonde blog cul blog erotique blog gay blog sexe blonde salope bondage botte femme botte bukkake chat lesbienne chat coquin chat gay gratuit chat gay chat lesbienne chat pour jeune chat sexe gratuit chat sexe chat webcam coquin sexy coquin couple amateur couple coquin cul amateur cul black cul de femme cul gratuit cul nu cul defloration defonce anal dessiner mangas dessous sexy dessous double anal double penetration dvd gay dvd mangas echange de jeune ejac facial ejac feminine ejac enorme bite enorme sein entre fille erotique gratuit erotique exhib amateur exhibition amateur extrait video sexe gratuit extrait video sexe faciale facialed fellation gay femme asiatique femme black femme chaude femme cochon femme coquin femme enceinte nu femme enceinte femme erotique femme gros sein femme grosse femme mature femme mure nu femme mure femme noire nu femme noire femme nu gratuit femme nu gratuite femme nu femme salope femme sex femme sexe femme sexy femme fetiche fetichisme collant fetichisme des pieds fetichisme pied fetichisme fille a poil fille arabe fille au pair fille chaude fille facile fille plage fille vierge fille first anal fist anal forte poitrine france coquin france coquine free gay pics free hentai free porn movies free porn pictures free porn video free porn free sexe free xxx galerie gay galerie sexe garcon nue gay amateur gay anal gay arabe gay bear gay beur gay black gay boys gay carangi gay chat gay cum gay escorte gay fr gay france gay free gay galerie gay hard gay marie carangi gay men gay muscle gay nu gay paris gay photo gay pics gay porn gay rencontre gay sex gay sexe gay site groups.msn.com gay video gay xxx gay gratuit sexe gros bite gros cul gros nichon gros penis gros sein gratuit gros sein naturel gros sein gros sexe gros teton grosse bite gay grosse bite grosse black grosse chatte grosse femme nu grosse femme grosse mature grosse poitrine grosse salope grossiste lingerie hard gay hard sexe hardcore party hardcore hentai free hentai gratuit hentai hard hentai video hentai x hentai histoire coquin histoire de cul histoire de sexe histoire erotique gratuite histoire erotique histoire gay homme femme homme gay humour sexe image cul image erotique image mangas image sexe interracial jeune naturiste jeune afrique jeune amatrice jeune chatte jeune cochon jeune et jolie jeune etudiante jeune femme nue jeune femme jeune fille au pair jeune fille jeune gay jeune lesbienne jeune nu jeune pucelle jeune pute jeune salope jeune sexe jeune soumise jeune vierge jeune lesbienne gratuit lesbienne gratuite lesbienne nu lesbienne photo lesbienne lingerie erotique lingerie feminine lingerie sexi lingerie sexy litterature erotique live video chat live webcam livre erotique mamie mangas adulte mangas erotique mangas hentai mangas image mangas porno mangas sex mangas sexe mangas sexy mangas x gratuits mangas x mangas massage coquin massage erotique masturbation femme masturbation gay mature fuck mature gratuit mature lesbian mature nu mature porn mature sex mature sexe mature sexy mature tales mature women mature young mature max hardcore mr sexe msn femme mure nichon nu amateur orgie pa gay page jeune paris voyeur partouze amateur partouze gay partouze party hardcore penetration anal penetration penis photo sexe amateur photo amateur photo belle femme photo black photo coquin photo couple amateur photo cul gratuit photo cul gratuite photo de bite photo de chatte photo de cul gratuit photo de cul gratuite photo de cul photo de femme a poil photo erotique gratuite photo femme enceinte photo femme nu gratuit photo femme nu gratuite photo femme nu photo femme sexy photo femme photo fille photo gay gratuit photo gay gratuite photo gay photo gratuite femme nu photo gratuite sexe photo gros sein photo grosse bite photo lesbienne gratuite photo lesbienne photo lingerie sexy photo lingerie photo penis photo salope photo sein photo sexe gratuit photo sexe gratuite photo sexe photo transsexuelle photo voyeur photo xxx pieds de femme poeme erotique poitrine pokemon hentai pompe porn attitude porn star porn porno amateur gratuit porno amateur porno asiatique porno black porno gay gratuit porno gay porno mature porno sexe porno xxx pornographie gratuite pornographie pornstar portail du sexe position sexe prenom anime prenom fille prenom garcon punition rencontre coquin rencontre cul rencontre erotique rencontre femme mariee rencontre femme mure rencontre femme rencontre fille rencontre gay rencontre lesbienne rencontre sexe gratuit rencontre sexe rencontre transsexuelle rencontre webcam salope arabe salope en chaleur salope gratuit salope gratuite salope mature sein de france sein enorme sein gratuit sein nu sein sex amateur gratuit sex amateur sex anal sex asiatique sex black sex femme sex gay sex mangas sex mature sex video sex videos sex webcam sex xxx sexe gay gratuit sexe amateur gratuit sexe amateur sexe anal sexe and gratuit sexe arabe sexe asiatique sexe beurette sexe black sexe en direct sexe extreme sexe feminin sexe femme sexe fr sexe free sexe gaulois sexe gay sexe gratos sexe gratui sexe gratuis sexe gratuit photo sexe gratuit video sexe gratuit sexe hard gratuit sexe hard sexe hardcore sexe homme sexe interracial sexe lesbienne sexe live sexe mangas sexe maroc sexe masculin sexe mature sexe photo sexe poilu sexe porno sexe rase sexe rencontre sexe video gratuit sexe video gratuite sexe video sexe videos sexe vieille sexe webcam sexe xxx sexe sexy black sexy lingerie sexy mangas sexy mature super voyeur teen amateur teen porn telechargement film x telecharger film x teton texte erotique transsexuelle travesti amateur triple penetration voyeur amateur voyeur beach voyeur france voyeur gratuit voyeur plage voyeur sex voyeur web voyeur web cam amateur webcam amateur webcam direct webcam gay webcam girls webcam sex webcam sexe webcam sexy webcam x x amateur x gay xxx gratuit xxx video xxx videos xxx young gay young porn zone coquin instrument de musique parole chanson parole de musique parole et musique parole paroles chansons paroles de musique paroles et musique paroles partition de musique partition gratuite partition guitare partition piano partition partitions de musique partitions gratuite partitions guitare partitions piano partitions tablature guitare tablature tablatures guitare tablatures dessin tatouage dessin tatouages henne modele de tatouage modele de tatouages motif tatouage motif tatouage motif tatouages photo tatouage photo tatouages piercing piercings tatoo tribal audrey tatou tatouage bas du dos tatouage chinois tatouage dragon tatouage au henne tatouage maori tatouage polynesien tatouage tribals tatouage papillon tatouage tribal tatouage tatouages bas du dos tatouages chinois tatouages dragon tatouages au henne tatouages maori tatouages polynesien tatouages papillon tatouages tribal tatouages accelerer telechargement achat logiciel achat logiciels acheter logiciel acheter logiciels acrobat ad aware adobe acrobat clone cd clone dvd codec divx codec telecharger computer software crack logiciel crack logiciels divx a telecharger divx codec divx player divx pro divx edonkey 2000 edonkey emule 0.46 emule fr emule france emule gratuit emule paradise emule plus emule telechargement gratuit emule telechargement emule telecharger gratuit emule telecharger emule free software graveur dvd imesh kazaa gratuit kazaa lite telecharger kazaa lite kazaa telecharger kazaa logiciel mp3 logiciel musique telechargement logiciel logiciel a telecharger gratuit logiciel a telecharger gratuitement logiciel a telecharger logiciel antivirus gratuit logiciel antivirus logiciel de dessin logiciel de gravure gratuit logiciel de gravure logiciel de mixage logiciel de navigation logiciel de telechargement de musique logiciel de telechargement gratuit logiciel de telechargement logiciel de traduction gratuit logiciel de traduction logiciel de dessin gratuit logiciel divx logiciel dvd logiciel educatif logiciel freeware logiciel gestion logiciel gratuit a telecharger logiciel gratuit logiciel gravure cd logiciel gravure dvd logiciel libre logiciel microsoft logiciel multimedia logiciel photo gratuit logiciel photo logiciel video logiciel webcam logiciel windows xp logiciel logiciels a telecharger logiciels antivirus logiciels mp3 logiciels musique telechargement logiciels logiciels creation site web logiciels de dessin logiciels de gravure gratuit logiciels de gravure logiciels de telechargement de musique logiciels de telechargement gratuit logiciels de telechargement logiciels de traduction gratuit logiciels de traduction logiciels divx logiciels dvd logiciels excel logiciels freeware logiciels gestion logiciels gratuit logiciels gravure cd logiciels gravure dvd logiciels libre logiciels microsoft logiciels multimedia logiciels photo gratuit logiciels photo logiciels pocket pc logiciels professionnel logiciels retouche photo logiciels video logiciels webcam logiciels windows xp logiciels mirc nero 6 nero 7 premium nero 7 nero burning rom nero burning nero express nero gratuit nero partition magic serveur emule shareaza telecharger skype software development software download software sortie dvd telecharge emule telechargement kazaa telechargement logiciels gratuit telechargement nero telechargement psp telechargement shareaza telechargement winzip telechargement codec telechargement com telecharger divx telechargement e mule telechargement emule gratuit telechargement gratuit logiciel telechargement gratuit telechargement logiciel gratuit telechargement logiciel telechargement logiciels telechargement telechargements codec telechargements e mule telechargements gratuit emule telechargements gratuit emule telechargements logiciel gratuit telechargements gratuit telechargements kazaa telechargements logiciel gratuit telechargements logiciel telechargements nero telechargements shareaza telechargements telecharger .com telecharger acrobat reader telecharger acrobat telecharger clone cd telecharger codec divx telecharger codec gratuit telecharger codec telecharger com telecharger driver telecharger e mule gratuit telecharger e mule gratuitement telecharger e mule telecharger emule gratuit telecharger emule gratuitement telecharger emule plus telecharger emule telecharger fr telecharger google earth telecharger google telecharger gratuit emule telecharger gratuit telecharger gratuitement e mule telecharger gratuitement emule telecharger gratuitement kazaa telecharger gratuitement logiciel telecharger gratuitement real player telecharger gratuitement shareaza telecharger gratuitement telecharger java telecharger kazaa en francais telecharger kazaa gratuit telecharger kazaa gratuitement telecharger kazaa lite gratuit telecharger kazaa lite telecharger kazaa little telecharger kazaa telecharger limewire telecharger logiciel divx telecharger logiciel easy studio telecharger nero 6 telecharger nero gratuit telecharger nero gratuitement telecharger nero telecharger norton antivirus 2005 telecharger norton antivirus telecharger power point telecharger real player gratuit telecharger real player telecharger shareaza gratuit telecharger shareaza gratuitement telecharger shareaza telecharger skype telecharger winamp telecharger winzip gratuit telecharger winzip telecharger word telecharger yahoo messenger telecharger traduction logiciel traduction logiciels vente logiciel winmx yahoo messenger zone alarm dvd porno dvd x extrait video porno film amateur film de cul film erotique film gay film porno gratuit film porno film pornographique film sex film sexe gratuit film sexe film x a telecharger film x amateur film x gratuit film x film xxx films de culs films erotiques films gratuit films porno gratuit films porno films pornographiques films x gratuit films x hot video porno film porno video sex video sex videos sexe video sexe videos telechargement film porno telechargement film x gratuit telechargement film x telechargement porno gratuit telechargement video x telechargement film x telechargements film x gratuit telechargements porno gratuit telecharger film x telecharger video x video amateur gratuit video amateur gratuite video amateur x video amateur video chat video coquin video cul gratuit video de cul video de cul gratuite video de cul video de sexe a telecharger video erotique gratuite video erotique video gay gratuit video gay gratuite video gay video gratuit video gratuite gay video gratuite sexe video hard video hentai gratuit video hentai video lesbienne gratuite video lesbienne video mature video porno telecharger video porno amateur video porno gratuit video porno gratuite video porno a telecharger video porno video salope video sex gratuit video sex video sexe amateur video sexe gratuit video sexe gratuite video sexe video sexy telecharger video video voyeur video x a telecharger video x amateur video x gratuit video x gratuite video x video xxx gratuit video xxx gratuite video xxx videos amateur videos de culs videos de culs videos erotiques videos gay gratuites videos gay videos gratuites sexe videos hard videos lesbiennes videos porno gratuit videos porno gratuites videos porno videos sex gratuit videos sex videos sexe gratuit videos sexe gratuites videos sexe videos sexy videos x gratuit videos x gratuites videos x videos xxx xxx video xxx videos astuce jeu pc astuce jeu video astuce jeu astuce jeux astuce pc astuce astuces jeux pc astuces pc code et astuce code et astuces code jeu video code jeux video pc astuce solution jeu pc solution jeu video solution jeu solution solutions jeux pc solutions jeux videos solutions trucs
Post a Comment
# posted by : 25/1/07 8:36 PM
: 25/1/07 8:36 PM
